| Years | Name | Stay | Notes |
| 1960 – 1962 | Pierre Smith | retired Methodist | |
| 1962 – 1968 | Henry & Elsie Beutler | Mennonite | |
| 1968 – 1970 | Bill & Cass Mai | 2 yrs | First VM pastor |
| 1970 – 1972 | John & Margie Slipkoff | 3 yrs | |
| 9/19/1972 – 12/19/1973 | Ron & Patty Laughlin | 1 yr, 3 mo | |
| 2/19/1974 – 6/19/1976 | Rod & Patty Behrens | 2 yrs, 4 mo | |
| 6/1/1976 – 5/31/1977 | Arthur Ford | 1 yr, 1 mo | |
| 6/1/1977 – 9/1/1983 | Harold & Shirley Maycumber | 6 yrs, 3 mo | |
| 9/19/1983 – 12/19/1986 | Clarence & Doreen Wiseman | 3 yrs, 3 mo | |
| 1/19/1987 – 8/25/1992 | Merwin & Arlene Dick | 5 yrs, 8 mo | |
| 10/19/1992 – 7/25/1999 | Richard & Dolores Weins | 6 yrs, 9 mo | |
| 10/31/1999 – 5/31/2002 | Bob & Robin White | 2 yrs, 7 mo | |
| Tim Kuenzi | non-VM supply | ||
| 1/27/2003 – 8/31/2008 | Eddie & Iti Simmons | 5 yrs, 7 mo | |
| Tim Kuenzi & Chuck Chapman | non-VM supply | ||
| 4/1/2009 – 1/31/2011 | Duane & Holly Scheidemantle | 1 yr, 8 mo | |
| Tim Kuenzi & Chuck Chapman | non-VM supply | ||
| 6/30/2011 – | Tim & Barb Douglass | 10 yrs + |